Alan Kay : July 2007 : A Conversation with CMU Faculty & Students

13K views · 10 years ago · talk · intermediate · evergreen

A July 2007 conversation between Alan Kay and faculty and students at Carnegie Mellon, mostly unscripted. Kay discusses the state of computing and how computer science should be taught.

HN people name it as their favorite Alan Kay talk because it is unscripted, and cite it for his blunt criticism of today's computing and CS curricula.

“Alan Kay, almost impolitely, tears into today's computing while talking at CMU”

7 comments from Hacker News

b
@blessedonekobo2024 · in “Alan Kay's talk at UCLA – Feb 2024 [video]”
This probably my favorite because it was mostly unscripted Alan Kay : July 2007 : A Conversation with CMU Faculty & Students ▶ this video
RecommendsView on HN
a
@agomez3142022 · in “Alan Kay: A Conversation with CMU Faculty and Students (2007) [video]”
Submitted the video to Hacker News.
RecommendsView on HN
s
@skadamat2017 · in “The Future of Programming (2013)”
I think you'll like the discussion he had at CMU a few years back, which focused a lot on the technology side of things ▶ this video
RecommendsView on HN
d
@da022016 · in “Alan Kay: July 2007: A Conversation with CMU Faculty and Students”
Submitted the video to Hacker News.
RecommendsView on HN
t
@tomcat272022 · in “A Case for an Open Source CS Curriculum [pdf] (2018)”
I'm glad an insider is thinking about this. But why do I have a feeling that it's written with an idea to make faculty life easy, not necessarily for a great student learning outcome, although that's what they say. Alan Kay (Turing Prize 2004) argues against current standard CS curriculum. ▶ this video Anyway few unrelated thoughts. --- The undergrad CS courses mostly do not deviate in content.The variance is in quality. "pick good professor over interesting course" paid off for me in university. Factors such as these matter: course pace, instructor and TA accessibility, course slides and other material quality, lecture interesting or boring etc. --- Isn't it surprising that one of the most watched courses is by an YouTube tutor with a credential no american university will ever take seriously for hiring even an adjunct teaching faculty? See Intro to Algorithms by Abdul Bari on YouTube
CitesView on HN
m
@michael_j_ward2022 · in “We’ve got a science opportunity overload: Launching the Wolfram Institute”
Alan Kay has part of the answer in this talk [0] where elucidates the errors taken by formal Comp Sci education. He claims there was a battle in the university between testable curriculum centered around Algorithms and builder curriculums based around hardware and distributed systems, and says it's a shame that algorithms won out. [0] Alan Kay : July 2007 : A Conversation with CMU Faculty & Students ▶ this video
CitesView on HN
j
@jstewartmobile2017 · in “Comparison of GreenArrays Chips with TI Micropower Controllers (2010) [pdf]”
Funny you should say that. Reminds me of this video[0] where Alan Kay, almost impolitely, tears into today's computing while talking at CMU. [0] ▶ this video