The Fallen of World War II

15.1M views · 10 years ago · documentary · evergreen

Neil Halloran's data-driven documentary on the human cost of World War II, using animated charts and maps to show how many died, where, and how that compares with other conflicts. It lets the viewer feel the scale of the numbers by pacing the visuals alongside narration.

HN people use it to get a true sense of the proportions of loss of life, and as an example of data told as a story.

“does a great job of giving a sense of what the proportions are of relative tragedies in terms of loss of life”

15 comments from Hacker News

z
@zug_zug2023 · in “9/11 in Realtime”
There's something so emotional and compelling about the spectacle of shared tragedy (even smaller ones like oceangate). However there's always a reminder in the back of my mind that what makes our heart leap is very poorly correlated with what things ought to scare us. I don't know if it's possible to "Reprogram" one's heart to worry less about very high-visibility low risk things (like air travel, or terrorism in the US) and care more about statistically probable ones that SHOULD scare us (heart disease and such), but I wish it were. ▶ this video does a great job of giving a sense of what the proportions are of relative tragedies in terms of loss of life.
RecommendsView on HN
j
@jdkee2022 · in “On “A Canticle for Leibowitz””
This video on the deaths in WWII will put things into perspective. See ▶ this video
RecommendsView on HN
j
@jdkee2022 · in “The Fallen of WWII”
Submitted the video to Hacker News.
RecommendsView on HN
r
@roveo2022 · in “Understanding the War in Ukraine”
Well, it's complicated. I think Putin's understanding of a "Nazi" is deeply connected to the Russian trauma of WWII that the West still doesn't get. Russians believe that due to the sheer number of lives lost, the USSR (and so Russia as its successor state) played _the_ central role in WWII. I encourage you to watch this video ▶ this video (the relevant parts start at about 4:40 and 9:40) I personally think that it makes no sense to talk about "who made the victory" because it was an allied effort and none of the allies could have done it alone. But at the same time, I think that westerners just don't get how personal and traumatic this was for the people of Russia. So, Putin is very sensitive to any view on WWII that differs from his. Things like "this was just two dictators (Stalin and Hitler) fighting". Or the view of some Ukrainian nationalists that the communists and the nazis were just both occupants (same view exists in Poland), or even that the nazis were liberators from communism. There's history of collaborationism in the Ukraine, as is everywhere, but not everywhere the collaborationists are viewed by a lot of people as national heroes, not as traitors who joined the aggressor (the nazis). I personally understand why this view exists, but for Putin and most Russians it's just outrageous. So, for Putin a nazi is mostly someone who disagrees with the Russian view on the role of the USSR in WWII. That includes nationalists from countries that Putin views as satellites/buffers (ex-USSR and socialist block), but Western countries that don't get how it looks from the Russian side, even those that were allies in WWII, are also tinted with this "nazi" color.
RecommendsView on HN
c
@chrisdhoover2021 · in “Battle of the Bulge”
It is an odd claim, the largest. I just did a cursory search and found several notable atrocities with larger numbers. Most occurred from over several days to over several months. I guess an argument could be that specifies in a single day or in a single hour but that kind of specificity trivializes the scale of atrocities committed against Poles, Serbs, and Jews. Large scale massacres includes: Palmiry, Liepaja, Katyn, Bubanj, and Borki This video is widely viewed and worth the time ▶ this video
RecommendsView on HN
a
@amai2020 · in “The Fallen of World War II”
Submitted the video to Hacker News.
RecommendsView on HN
p
@prawn2016 · in “The Fallen of World War II”
Submitted the video to Hacker News.
RecommendsView on HN
s
@socalgal22025 · in “Hiroshima (1946)”
Why is this special? The Japanese killed ~7 million Chinese, 0.5 to 1 million Filipinos, 500k in Korea, you can keep adding them up. Then Japan loses 0.2% of all their atrocities and it's the worst thing ever? No, it's not the worst thing ever, not even close. Sure, we'd all like it to never happen again. But if I had to pick one thing not happening again I'd pick saving all others that died in WW2 over this one incident. ▶ this video There's also the argument that it saved more lives than the deaths it caused. The same can not be said for Japan's atrocities.
CitesView on HN
0
@0xDEAFBEAD2025 · in “Meta Wants More AI Bots on Facebook and Instagram”
That quote may sound vaguely creepy, but fundamentally he's got a good point. The most brutal wars tend to be wars where both sides are roughly evenly matched. WW1 and WW2 were so deadly because both alliances consisted of several industrialized nations. We're lucky that we haven't seen total war between major industrial powers since that time: ▶ this video
B
@Beijinger2024 · in “300k airplanes in five years”
The posted article gives quite an impressive Soviet plane production. 50% of that of the US. It was Russia that won the war. ▶ this video And regarding the Ukraine war. Russia's industrial might is underestimated. And while it can not match that of the West, as a word of caution: China has more industrial capacity than the EU and US combined. Wars have the nasty habit of taking unexpected turns...
CitesView on HN
o
@olivermarks2023 · in “Jerry Siegel, Joe Shuster, and the Birth of Superman”
70 million people died over six years in WWII, the vast majority Russians. 1930's USA has little bearing on European geopolitics and the creation of golden era superman comics. An animated data-driven documentary about war and peace, The Fallen of World War II looks at the human cost of the second World War and sizes up the numbers to other wars in history, including trends in recent conflicts. ▶ this video
CitesView on HN
s
@supernova87a2021 · in “Underrated Reasons to Be Thankful”
There is really something to the idea that despite the daily news and political doomsaying that goes on every day, it's hard for people to remember or celebrate the long progression that we've experienced towards living in the most peaceful, materially prosperous, and positive trajectory time in the history of humanity. (I think there was a podcast on Hidden Brain about this. Also video like this ▶ this video). It's really good to periodically think about how much we benefit from, say, the miracles of air conditioning, available infrastructure and cheap travel beyond your town, clean water and air, medicine, vaccines, public health -- and reset what you're grateful for. And stop making every little transgression of modern life feel like a disastrous setback. But of course it's very unfashionable to point this out when someone's <xyz> cause is being neglected, or is in the news and everyone is outraged. Of course when you make such comparisons you get hissed out of a room for being so callous, because anyone's relative suffering is supposed to be treated with utmost respect. And the short, acute, headline making problems are always louder than the long progression of gradual improvement. But taken in perspective, by intelligent people who can discuss such things, we've really reached the age of 1% problems. (which are being exposed because our huge disastrous human-generated conflicts, etc. are decreased compared to 100 years ago). Health, social issues, etc. are such luxuries to have problems about now (and glad to have them discovered and debated), but remember how wonderful a time we live in. We aren't generally dying of terrible diseases during childhood, etc. or because of world wars. More people are living longer to experience the wonders of humanity than ever before. Although, things like climate change we'd better allow to rise to the top of our list of problems, soon... Anyway, definitely very thankful for all these things, and all the daily unsung people who make our humanity's progress possible.
CitesView on HN